Utada Net.com Forum Index
   General Utada Discussion
   JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
Poster Thread
Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US
Hikki Obsessed
Joined: 2007/2/10
A/S/L 18/GQ?/CA
Posts: 431
Quote:

Amaterasu wrote:
Quote:
On another note, it isn't wise to tell an upset Hikki fan to "chill out." We're the reason she's so terrified to come back here, remember? ;D


If BoA was equally or more successful than the Wonder Girls, it would be no more than an accomplishment according to many of the posts here. After all, BoA has admitted being to being a manufactured star.

Except BoA doesn't stupidly trash-talk other artists, even through implication, to my knowledge. Even if JYP didn't intend to offend, it was an enormously idiotic thing to say. After all, no one was anything but congratulatory to the Wonder Girls when the original thread discussing their breakthrough was posted here- I personally had no interest in them, so I didn't contribute, but it wasn't like I actively disliked them then, nor do I now. However, JYP could have remained securely within the confines of self-appreciation: he didn't have to degrade the work other artists have put into their crossover attempts. A more appropriate route for him to have taken would have been acknowledgment for the Wonder Girls and everything they've done; instead he took most of the credit for his management skills and downplayed the efforts of other serious artists who are equally if not more successful. Again, while he wasn't extremely hostile about it and it's not something I'll be losing any sleep over, it was highly unnecessary and, I feel, a case of passive-aggressive behavior at its worse.

Quote:

Pips_Paradise wrote:
They deserve a break or at least a fair chance to succeed.

All the best to the Wonder Girls (even if they are essentially money-making musical vendor machines taking the form of living, breathing, singing human beings)! JYP and his inflated ego can take a hike, though. :]
_________________
Posted on: 2009/11/23 17:29
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Polyrhythm 2009/11/21 12:39
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US meekobiscuit 2009/11/21 12:53
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/21 13:32
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/11/21 12:46
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/21 13:36
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US BokuWaDevil光 2009/11/21 13:45
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Amaterasu 2009/11/21 15:15
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Kumachang 2009/11/21 15:14
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/21 16:44
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US aquaticdragons 2009/11/22 0:15
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US ItsDaveyJ 2009/11/22 2:25
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Pips_Paradise 2009/11/22 8:18
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/22 13:41
             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US ItsDaveyJ 2009/11/23 3:52
               Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Amaterasu 2009/11/23 7:36
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/23 8:27
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/11/23 10:44
                   Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US percypenn 2009/11/23 11:14
                     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/11/23 13:48
                     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Polyrhythm 2009/11/23 14:21
                       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Amaterasu 2009/11/23 15:26
                         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Pips_Paradise 2009/11/23 16:03
                         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/11/23 17:29
                           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Pips_Paradise 2009/11/24 3:22
                             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Taboo 2009/11/30 23:57
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/22 10:04
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US kayoko 2009/11/22 10:34
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US teiku5 2009/11/22 14:57
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US soulhunter14 2009/11/22 20:59
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US SwallowTail 2009/11/22 21:02
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US ramenbox 2009/11/23 2:24
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/12/1 17:04
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US merchantdog2 2009/12/4 2:16
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US jreuij 2009/12/8 4:34
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US zunecrazy 2009/12/8 10:10
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US felisity 2009/12/8 16:41
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US ramenbox 2009/12/9 8:23
             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US percypenn 2009/12/9 10:48
               Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Hikaruxhide 2009/12/9 11:04
               Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US gantzman246 2009/12/9 11:29
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Ultra_Red 2009/12/15 10:38
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Marce 2009/12/16 8:22
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US gantzman246 2009/12/15 12:26
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Ultra_Red 2009/12/16 6:03
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/12/16 7:21
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US gantzman246 2009/12/16 9:04
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Ultra_Red 2009/12/16 9:41
             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US gantzman246 2009/12/16 12:17
               Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/12/16 14:03
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US TurtleFu 2009/12/16 14:10
                   Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/12/16 14:18
                     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US A5UKA 2009/12/16 15:54
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Jiremi 2010/4/17 19:58
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US razzle 2010/4/17 22:48
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US DjPho 2010/4/18 5:42
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Jiremi 2010/4/18 13:37
             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Pips_Paradise 2010/4/19 6:05
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2010/4/19 12:59
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Kumabear 2010/4/19 17:28
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Jiremi 2010/4/19 18:37
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic