Utada Net.com Forum Index
   General Utada Discussion
   JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
Poster Thread
  •  Unregistered
      Unregistered
Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US
guest_Unregistered
Well, she's an established artist in Japan, 'tis true. And her English albums have gathered a large group of fans, some of whom cross over by getting into her Japanese music. There are some wonderful Asian musicians that have large followings in America, but we have yet to see an Asian artist have the American following of someone like Alanis Morissette, for example.

Wonder Girls are indeed a product to be sold, although you could really say that about most musicians in general. Hikki sticks to her guns, even if others produce her English stuff. The more I listen to TiTO, for example, the more I hear reminiscences of stuff like "Keep Tryin'" and "Traveling". So she always carries the same flavor in all her stuff, but manages to reinvent herself for each album, not unlike Madonna.

Having said that, I think there might be something to the thought of changing your music to fit a certain market. Hikki herself has acknowledged that some of the reasons for doing an R&B album is because "that's what's popular in the US right now". Yet it's still her personal flavor that shows through in her songwriting, even on an album like TiTO.

I think Americans need to get over the xenophobia and think against the J-pop/A-pop stereotypes that Asian musicians seem to be burdened with. We're all people and it's hard for me to see why Americans have an issue with that.
Posted on: 2009/11/21 13:32
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Polyrhythm 2009/11/21 12:39
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US meekobiscuit 2009/11/21 12:53
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/21 13:32
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/11/21 12:46
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/21 13:36
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US BokuWaDevil光 2009/11/21 13:45
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Amaterasu 2009/11/21 15:15
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Kumachang 2009/11/21 15:14
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/21 16:44
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US aquaticdragons 2009/11/22 0:15
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US ItsDaveyJ 2009/11/22 2:25
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Pips_Paradise 2009/11/22 8:18
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/22 13:41
             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US ItsDaveyJ 2009/11/23 3:52
               Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Amaterasu 2009/11/23 7:36
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/23 8:27
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/11/23 10:44
                   Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US percypenn 2009/11/23 11:14
                     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/11/23 13:48
                     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Polyrhythm 2009/11/23 14:21
                       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Amaterasu 2009/11/23 15:26
                         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Pips_Paradise 2009/11/23 16:03
                         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/11/23 17:29
                           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Pips_Paradise 2009/11/24 3:22
                             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Taboo 2009/11/30 23:57
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/11/22 10:04
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US kayoko 2009/11/22 10:34
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US teiku5 2009/11/22 14:57
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US soulhunter14 2009/11/22 20:59
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US SwallowTail 2009/11/22 21:02
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US ramenbox 2009/11/23 2:24
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/12/1 17:04
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US merchantdog2 2009/12/4 2:16
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US jreuij 2009/12/8 4:34
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US zunecrazy 2009/12/8 10:10
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US felisity 2009/12/8 16:41
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US ramenbox 2009/12/9 8:23
             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US percypenn 2009/12/9 10:48
               Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Hikaruxhide 2009/12/9 11:04
               Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US gantzman246 2009/12/9 11:29
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Ultra_Red 2009/12/15 10:38
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Marce 2009/12/16 8:22
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US gantzman246 2009/12/15 12:26
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Ultra_Red 2009/12/16 6:03
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2009/12/16 7:21
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US gantzman246 2009/12/16 9:04
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Ultra_Red 2009/12/16 9:41
             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US gantzman246 2009/12/16 12:17
               Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/12/16 14:03
                 Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US TurtleFu 2009/12/16 14:10
                   Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Shurikid 2009/12/16 14:18
                     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US A5UKA 2009/12/16 15:54
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Jiremi 2010/4/17 19:58
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US razzle 2010/4/17 22:48
         Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US DjPho 2010/4/18 5:42
           Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Jiremi 2010/4/18 13:37
             Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Pips_Paradise 2010/4/19 6:05
     Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Unregistered 2010/4/19 12:59
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Kumabear 2010/4/19 17:28
       Re: JYP thinks Utada "failed" in the US Jiremi 2010/4/19 18:37
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic